Satoshi MailBeta Open in Satoshi Mail

James A. Donald

From Satoshipedia, the Satoshi Mail encyclopedia

James A. Donald took part in the Cryptography mailing list. Two days after Satoshi posted the white paper he wrote the first public reply: “We very, very much need such a system, but the way I understand your proposal, it does not seem to scale to the required size.” (the thread). Satoshi's answers in that thread are some of his earliest explanations of how Bitcoin would scale.

Donald was also copied on Satoshi's November 2008 pre-release source code, along with Hal Finney and Ray Dillinger.

In the archive

10 messages in 1 conversations with Satoshi.

See also

Primary sources

The messages and commits this article draws on, in Satoshi Mail and where they were first published.

  1. Bitcoin P2P e-cash paper, Cryptography mailing list, 2 November 2008. Original source

Published by Tyler Howell for Satoshi Mail. Written with AI assistance from the sources listed above and checked against them. Last updated 22 October 2026. Spotted an error? Email itstylerhowell@gmail.com (how articles are made).

Categories: People · Cypherpunks